727 Old Montauk HighwayMontauk11954USA
Serviced apartment
Show more hotels

About Beachcomber

Located in Montauk in East Hampton at the tip of the South Fork, Long Island, New York, the Beachcomber is a relaxed hotel with awesome amenities such as private access to the beach. The property is walking distance to the shops and restaurants of Montauk Village.

Bright, comfortable, spacious rooms range from studios to two-bedroom suites. Most feature fully equipped kitchens with microwaves and dishwashers; some have sofabeds, fireplaces and private decks.

The Beachcomber entices guests to unwind with its outdoor pool (seasonal), tennis court and sauna. The Beachcomber entices guests to unwind with its outdoor pool (seasonal) and make use of it’s private beach, tennis court and sauna.

There are plenty of places to dine nearby whether you’re into fresh pastries and coffee in the morning or the catch of the day. Options include John’s Pancake House, Coast Restaurant and Montauk Brewing Company.

Along with the beach, guests have quite a few places to explore such as the Historic Montauk Point Lighthouse and Wolffer Estate Vineyard.


727 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, 11954, USA
Telephone: +1(631)6682894 | Official Homepage

Top amenities

  • Free WiFi in lobby
  • Free WiFi in rooms
  • Pool
  • Spa
  • Parking
  • Pets
  • A/C
  • Restaurant
  • Hotel bar
  • Gym

All amenities

Hotel facilities

  • Car park
  • Deck chairs / Sun loungers
  • Free WiFi in lobby
  • Non-smoking rooms
  • Outdoor swimming pool
  • Parasols
  • Terrace
  • Towels at the pool / beach
  • WiFi in lobby

Room facilities

  • Air conditioning
  • Bathroom with shower
  • Cable TV
  • Central heating
  • Electric kettle
  • Fan
  • Free WiFi in rooms
  • Fridge
  • Internet
  • Ironing board
  • Kitchen / Kitchenette
  • Microwave
  • Telephone
  • Television
  • WiFi in rooms

Wellness / Spa

  • Sauna

For children

  • Organised activities for kids

Arrival / Departure

  • Check-in: 15:00
  • Check-out: 11:00

Positive Reviews

Proximity to beach

This seasonal hotel gets accolades from guests thanks to its ability to cater to summer travelers through its proximity to the beach. There is a private beach directly across the road from the hotel that guests love thanks to their ability to quickly walk to it.

Ocean views great

Guests say that the ocean views at Beachcomber are a compelling reason to lodge at the hotel. Rooms feature a balcony that guests insist provide some excellent views of the ocean waves, which can be seen just across the street from the balconies.

Clean and spacious

Most guests to this destination agree that the rooms are quite spacious and clean, offering ample room for multiple adults to stretch out comfortably after a long day.

Negative Reviews

Walls thin

There are quite a number of complaints involving the thickness of the walls at this location. Guests assume that the walls must be quite thin, as there are complaints that guests in adjoining rooms can be too easily heard during the day and night.

Noisy appliances

Continuing with the noise theme, guests assert that there are some overly noisy appliances included in the rooms at Beachcomber. Specifically, the air conditioning units sometimes run noisily, and guests say that the fridges in particularly run poorly, distracting them at night.

Beds “could be better”

Guests note that the beds here could be better, and that sometimes the mattresses are too firm to comfortably sleep upon. There are also reports that the springs in some mattresses pop out, causing discomfort.

Visitors to this hotel were also interested in...

More Top Hotels

Rating Overview

Rating trivago Rating Index based on 518 reviews across the web
8.7 /10
  • Expedia
    9.2 /10
    9.2 /10
  • other websites
    8.1 /10
8.7 out of 10 based on 518 reviews