Hotels in Brookhaven (New York State, USA)

In order to supply this free comparison, booking sites pay us a fee when a user clicks on their specific offer. We do not display any offers (including cheaper offers) that do not meet our minimum fee requirements. Cheaper offers may on occasion be available under "More deals" as we request updated offers from online booking sites when you click that button. Learn how trivago works.

77 hotels in Brookhaven

  1. Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook-long Island By Ihg

    Indoor pool and fitness facilities
    See prices from 13 sites
    from$192
  2. Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven

    Convenient Access to Local Retail
    See prices from 15 sites
    from$222
  3. 2 Bedroom Apartment Minutes Away From Gambling, Bars, Restaurants, Water Park...

    Select dates to see exact prices
  4. Two Bedroom, Living/dining Room

    Select dates to see exact prices
  5. Davis Park Fire Island Retreat

    Select dates to see exact prices
  6. Cozy and Modern 2-bedroom apartment in lovely Yaphank

    Select dates to see exact prices
  7. Paradise Citadel

    Select dates to see exact prices
  8. Large Coastal Bohemian Getaway W/ Pool

    Select dates to see exact prices
  9. Beachfront Paradise With Private Walk To Beach

    Select dates to see exact prices
  10. Natures Retreat: Serene Woodland Haven Near Nyc

    Select dates to see exact prices
  11. Oceanfront Davis Park Fi Split Ac Sleeps 10

    Select dates to see exact prices
  12. Bellport Village Gem

    Select dates to see exact prices
  13. LoveFINS

    Direct Fire Island beachfront access
    Select dates to see exact prices
  14. Hawkins Castle

    Select dates to see exact prices
  15. Charming 4 bedroom house in heart of Bellport Village. Summer season rental 18k

    Select dates to see exact prices
  16. Charming 4 bedroom house in heart of Bellport Village. Fall / winter rental

    Select dates to see exact prices
  17. Resort-Style Home w/ Pool, Bar & Outdoor Kitchen

    Select dates to see exact prices
  18. Enjoy quiet nights with a fireplace in Bellport home

    Select dates to see exact prices
  19. Charming Cottage Getaway, 5 Minutes East Of Bellport Village

    Select dates to see exact prices
  20. Bellport Village Spacious House With Heated-Pool, Hot-Tub & Ping-Pong

    Select dates to see exact prices
  21. Charming Converted Barn And Cottage Walk To The Fire Island Ferry, Rental By Mo.

    Select dates to see exact prices
  22. 5 Bedroom Waterfront Escape

    Select dates to see exact prices
  23. Cozy Two-bedroom Cottage In Long Islands Bucolic Brookhaven Hamlet

    Select dates to see exact prices
  24. Beach House Scandinavian Style On Long Island

    Select dates to see exact prices
  25. Otis By The Beach 1 Bedroom + 1 Living Room With Sofabed !

    Select dates to see exact prices
  26. Ocean Ridge Fi House Large Hot Tub With A/c Sleeps (10) Pets Allowed

    Select dates to see exact prices
  27. Water Views From This Immaculate, Sunny Home In Bellport Village - Walk To All

    Select dates to see exact prices
  28. Beach/ Golf/ Tennis/ Shopping/ Playhouse/ Theater/ Pool/ Playground/ Concerts.

    Select dates to see exact prices
  29. 3-bedroom house in delightful Mastic with WiFi, AC

    Select dates to see exact prices
  30. Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island

    On-site fitness center available daily
    See prices from 16 sites
    from$164
  31. Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven

    Direct Access to Long Island Expressway
    See prices from 13 sites
    from$169
  32. Holiday Inn Long Island - Islip Arpt East By Ihg

    Onsite Sonoma Grill Restaurant Bar
    See prices from 14 sites
    from$114
  33. Fairfield Inn Medford Long Island

    Convenient access to major highways
    See prices from 13 sites
    from$204
  34. La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport

    On-site fitness center access
    See prices from 14 sites
    from$97
  35. 112 Motel

    Upgraded rooms with whirlpool tubs
    See prices from 10 sites
    from$179

The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.

Popular hotel categories in Brookhaven

When to book a hotel in Brookhaven

  • Cheapest month: February
    $260 per night
  • Yearly typical price
    $332 per night
  • Peak month: July
    $636 per night

Frequently Asked Questions about Brookhaven

  • When is the cheapest time to book a hotel in Brookhaven?

    February is usually the cheapest month to book a hotel in Brookhaven, with typical prices around $260 per night based on 150 price comparisons.

  • When are hotel prices highest in Brookhaven?

    Hotel prices in Brookhaven are usually highest during July, with typical prices around $636 per night.

  • How much does a hotel in Brookhaven cost per night?

    Hotel prices in Brookhaven usually range from $227 per night to $777 per night, with typical prices around $332 per night.

  • How do hotel prices in Brookhaven change throughout the year?

    Hotel prices in Brookhaven are typically lowest in February at around $260 per night, rising to around $636 per night in July.

  • November

    2026

    $345
    $280 — $795
  • December

    2026

    $285
    $234 — $333
  • January

    2027

    $312
    $272 — $378
  • February

    2027

    $260
    $227 — $331
  • March

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • April

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • May

    2027

    $332
    $266 — $432
  • June

    2027

    $334
    $318 — $425
  • July

    2027

    $636
    $611 — $777
  • August

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • September

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • October

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

Frequently Asked Questions about Brookhaven

Hotels in Brookhaven

These hotels may also be interesting for you...

Points of Interest - Brookhaven

Top Destinations

More Top Destinations