Hotels in New Buffalo (Michigan, USA)

In order to supply this free comparison, booking sites pay us a fee when a user clicks on their specific offer. We do not display any offers (including cheaper offers) that do not meet our minimum fee requirements. Cheaper offers may on occasion be available under "More deals" as we request updated offers from online booking sites when you click that button. Learn how trivago works.

472 hotels in New Buffalo

  1. Four Winds Casino Resort

    3 Stars
    Diverse on-site dining and restaurants
    See prices from 3 sites
    from$316
  2. Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo, Mi By Ihg

    3 Stars
    Convenient access to I-94 highway
    Select dates to see exact prices
  3. Quality Inn Near Interstate I94

    3 Stars
    Indoor heated pool and spa
    Select dates to see exact prices
  4. Baymont by Wyndham New Buffalo

    3 Stars
    Suites with private whirlpool tubs
    Select dates to see exact prices
  5. Fairfield Inn & Suites New Buffalo

    3 Stars
    Proximity to Regional Attractions
    Select dates to see exact prices
  6. The Neighborhood Hotel Grand Beach

    4 Stars
    Seasonal pool and fire pits
    Select dates to see exact prices
  7. The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo

    2 Stars
    Walkable access to downtown attractions
    Select dates to see exact prices
  8. New Buffalo Inn & Spa

    Contactless digital check-in process
    Select dates to see exact prices
  9. Walking Distance To Beach And Shops

    Select dates to see exact prices
  10. Eagles Beach Nest II

    Select dates to see exact prices
  11. Adorable Cottage New Buffalo. Near Grand Beach

    Select dates to see exact prices
  12. Historic Downtown Beach Bungalow

    Select dates to see exact prices
  13. Soak Up Some Sunshine At The Cozy Soulshine Inn

    Select dates to see exact prices
  14. Peach By The Beach! 1 Bdrm Apt Close To Downtown

    Select dates to see exact prices
  15. Relax And Enjoy. Walk To Beach & Restaurants

    Select dates to see exact prices
  16. Farmstead Guest Home 2

    Select dates to see exact prices
  17. Grand Beach - Escape Large Family Home

    Select dates to see exact prices
  18. Summer Weeks Available And Discounted. Travel Local !

    Select dates to see exact prices
  19. New, Luxury Magnolia-Style Cottage - Walk To Town & Beach!

    Select dates to see exact prices
  20. Woodsy Relaxing Escape

    Select dates to see exact prices
  21. Aqua Hot Tub Gas Firepit Large Yard Walk To Restaurants Shops And Breweries

    Select dates to see exact prices
  22. The Harbor Grand

    Select dates to see exact prices
  23. Celebration House Sleeps 12 4 Bedroom 2 1/2 Bath Private Beach In-ground Pool

    Select dates to see exact prices
  24. SureStay Hotel New Buffalo

    2 Stars
    Select dates to see exact prices
  25. Great Grand Beach Pool House, Hot Tub, Walk To Beach, Games

    Select dates to see exact prices
  26. Perfectly Located New Buffalo Condo With Association Pool! 2019 Calendar Now Open!

    Select dates to see exact prices
  27. Remodeled 4 Br 2 Ba Dog Friendly Home Across From The Marina

    Select dates to see exact prices
  28. Mac's Bluff

    Select dates to see exact prices
  29. Downtown Hideaway

    Select dates to see exact prices
  30. Nothin Dune

    Select dates to see exact prices
  31. Happy Thoughts Cottage

    Select dates to see exact prices
  32. The Pelton House

    Select dates to see exact prices
  33. Surf's Up

    Select dates to see exact prices
  34. Eagles Nest

    Select dates to see exact prices
  35. The Sunset House

    Select dates to see exact prices

The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.

Popular hotel categories in New Buffalo

When to book a hotel in New Buffalo

  • Cheapest month: March
    $134 per night
  • Yearly typical price
    $175 per night
  • Peak month: December
    $408 per night

Frequently Asked Questions about New Buffalo

  • When is the cheapest time to book a hotel in New Buffalo?

    March is usually the cheapest month to book a hotel in New Buffalo, with typical prices around $134 per night based on 30 price comparisons.

  • When are hotel prices highest in New Buffalo?

    Hotel prices in New Buffalo are usually highest during December, with typical prices around $408 per night.

  • How much does a hotel in New Buffalo cost per night?

    Hotel prices in New Buffalo usually range from $109 per night to $756 per night, with typical prices around $175 per night.

  • How do hotel prices in New Buffalo change throughout the year?

    Hotel prices in New Buffalo are typically lowest in March at around $134 per night, rising to around $408 per night in December.

  • November

    2026

    $150
    $149 — $514
  • December

    2026

    $408
    $317 — $756
  • January

    2027

    $190
    $121 — $260
  • February

    2027

    $159
    $98 — $212
  • March

    2027

    $134
    $109 — $228
  • April

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • May

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • June

    2027

    $253
    $238 — $299
  • July

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • August

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • September

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • October

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

Frequently Asked Questions about New Buffalo

Hotels in New Buffalo

These hotels may also be interesting for you...

Points of Interest - New Buffalo

Top Destinations

More Top Destinations