Hotels in Oyster Bay (New York State, USA)

In order to supply this free comparison, booking sites pay us a fee when a user clicks on their specific offer. We do not display any offers (including cheaper offers) that do not meet our minimum fee requirements. Cheaper offers may on occasion be available under "More deals" as we request updated offers from online booking sites when you click that button. Learn how trivago works.

21 hotels in Oyster Bay

  1. Holiday Inn Plainview-Long Island by IHG

    3 Stars
    Utilize 24-Hour Fitness Center Facilities
    See prices from 14 sites
    from$218
  2. Econo Lodge Hicksville - Long Island

    2 Stars
    Convenient access to major parkways
    See prices from 15 sites
    from$174
  3. TownePlace Suites Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale

    3 Stars
    Walking distance to local shopping
    See prices from 15 sites
    from$242
  4. Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale

    3 Stars
    Walkable access to local dining
    See prices from 15 sites
    from$300
  5. Beach Bungalow In Bayville, Ny

    Select dates to see exact prices
  6. Hampton Style Summer Getaway - Spacious 4-bedroom House With Private Pool

    Select dates to see exact prices
  7. Private 1BR Suite with Jacuzzi in Jericho

    Select dates to see exact prices
  8. Curated Suite with Soaking Tub and Walk to Whole Foods

    Select dates to see exact prices
  9. Modern Jericho 3BR Top Floor, Walk to everything

    Select dates to see exact prices
  10. 3 Bedroom Oasis With A Cozy Home Feel. Walk To Shops, Restaurants.

    Select dates to see exact prices
  11. Meadowbrook Motor Lodge

    2 Stars
    Select dates to see exact prices
  12. Residence Inn Plainview Long Island

    3 Stars
    Select dates to see exact prices
  13. Chic Private 1br Suite/walk To Shops

    Select dates to see exact prices
  14. Guest Suite In Oyster Bay

    Select dates to see exact prices
  15. East Norwich Inn

    3 Stars
    Access to on-site fitness center
    See prices from 6 sites
    from$134
  16. Tides Inn at Stehli Beach

    3 Stars
    Seasonal pool and tennis courts
    See prices from 6 sites
    from$152
  17. Hampton Inn & Suites Huntington Downtown

    3 Stars
    Walkable access to downtown Huntington
    See prices from 14 sites
    from$256
  18. The Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel

    4 Stars
    Dine at Volpe Italian Restaurant
    See prices from 13 sites
    from$261
  19. SureStay Plus by Best Western Woodbury Inn

    3 Stars
    On-site fitness center access
    See prices from 16 sites
    from$144
  20. Days Inn by Wyndham Woodbury Long Island

    2 Stars
    Convenient Access to Local Amenities
    See prices from 7 sites
    from$178
  21. Inn At Jericho

    2 Stars
    Walk to NYCB Theatre Westbury
    See prices from 9 sites
    from$141
  22. The Mansion at Glen Cove

    4 Stars
    Access Outdoor Recreation and Pools
    See prices from 8 sites
    from$321
  23. Four Points by Sheraton Melville Long Island

    3 Stars
    On-site restaurant and bar dining
    See prices from 14 sites
    from$224
  24. Comfort Inn Syosset-Long Island

    3 Stars
    On-site fitness and laundry facilities
    See prices from 13 sites
    from$248
  25. Oheka Castle

    3 Stars
    On-site OHK Bar and Restaurant
    See prices from 13 sites
    from$378
  26. Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham

    4 Stars
    Proximity to Westbury Music Fair
    See prices from 19 sites
    from$295
  27. Hilton Garden Inn Melville

    3 Stars
    Convenient access to Long Island attractions
    See prices from 13 sites
    from$246
  28. Red Roof PLUS+ Long Island - Garden City

    3 Stars
    Walk to Roosevelt Field Mall
    See prices from 15 sites
    from$178
  29. Hilton Garden Inn Roslyn

    3 Stars
    Proximity to Roslyn and Golf
    See prices from 14 sites
    from$256
  30. Extended Stay America - Long Island - Bethpage

    3 Stars
    In-room kitchenettes with full refrigerators
    See prices from 11 sites
    from$189
  31. Homewood Suites by Hilton Long Island-Melville

    3 Stars
    Direct access to Interstate 495
    See prices from 13 sites
    from$245
  32. Hilton Long Island/Huntington

    3 Stars
    Multiple on-site dining options available
    See prices from 14 sites
    from$256
  33. Hyatt Place Garden City

    3 Stars
    Walk to nearby retail centers
    See prices from 17 sites
    from$213
  34. Whitman Motor Lodge

    2 Stars
    Proximity to Huntington Area Attractions
    See prices from 8 sites
    from$223
  35. Marriott Melville Long Island

    4 Stars
    Proximity to Walt Whitman Shops
    See prices from 10 sites
    from$306

The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.

When to book a hotel in Oyster Bay

  • Cheapest month: March
    $278 per night
  • Yearly typical price
    $327 per night
  • Peak month: November
    $492 per night

Frequently Asked Questions about Oyster Bay

  • When is the cheapest time to book a hotel in Oyster Bay?

    March is usually the cheapest month to book a hotel in Oyster Bay, with typical prices around $278 per night based on 35 price comparisons.

  • When are hotel prices highest in Oyster Bay?

    Hotel prices in Oyster Bay are usually highest during November, with typical prices around $492 per night.

  • How much does a hotel in Oyster Bay cost per night?

    Hotel prices in Oyster Bay usually range from $262 per night to $694 per night, with typical prices around $327 per night.

  • How do hotel prices in Oyster Bay change throughout the year?

    Hotel prices in Oyster Bay are typically lowest in March at around $278 per night, rising to around $492 per night in November.

  • November

    2026

    $492
    $254 — $694
  • December

    2026

    $318
    $254 — $437
  • January

    2027

    $354
    $266 — $445
  • February

    2027

    $327
    $308 — $517
  • March

    2027

    $278
    $262 — $387
  • April

    2027

    $326
    $300 — $440
  • May

    2027

    $311
    $295 — $422
  • June

    2027

    $341
    $305 — $428
  • July

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • August

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • September

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

  • October

    2027

    Select dates to see exact prices

Frequently Asked Questions about Oyster Bay

Hotels in Oyster Bay

These hotels may also be interesting for you...

Points of Interest - Oyster Bay

Top Destinations

More Top Destinations